Under $25 – Pagan Isle Apothecary

Under $25

Looking for a little magic without breaking the bank? Our Gifts Under $25 collection is filled with enchanting picks perfect for witches on a budget, thoughtful gift-givers, or anyone who loves a bit of mystical sparkle.

Mystery Coffin Capsules

Mystery Coffin Capsules

$10.00 USD

Cabinet of Curiosities featuring a curated assortment of mystical objects, crystals, and apothecary-inspired items, arranged in a dark, enchanted display for magical decor and discovery.

Cabinet of Curiosities | Witchy Mystery Bags

$22.95 USD

Sold out

Toast At Twilight wax melt blending cozy warmth with a dark twilight aesthetic

Toast at Twilight Wax Melts | Romantic Evening Scent

$6.25 USD

Graveyard Roses wax melt featuring deep rose notes with a dark romantic gothic vibe

Graveyard Roses Wax Melts | Dark Floral Gothic Scent

$6.25 USD

Zombie Zest Fest wax melt with bright citrus tones in a spooky gothic aesthetic

Zombie Zest Fest Wax Melts | Bright & Spooky Citrus

$6.25 USD

Dark apothecary-style Witch’s Brew wax melt with mystical gothic tones

Witch’s Brew Wax Melts | Classic Seasonal Scent

$6.25 USD

Monster Mash wax melt with playful spooky colors and Halloween-inspired styling

Monster Mash Wax Melts | Fun Spooky Scent

$6.25 USD

Dark Unicorn wax melt blending fantasy magic with a dark gothic aesthetic

Dark Unicorn Wax Melts | Sweet Fantasy Scent

$6.25 USD

Moonlit Mischief wax melt with magical nighttime vibes and gothic charm

Moonlit Mischief Wax Melts | Cheeky, Spicy Scent

$6.25 USD

Button Eyes wax melt inspired by spooky cute aesthetics and gothic decor

Button Eyes Wax Melts | Sweet & Spooky Scent

$6.25 USD

Funny coffee mug with skeleton wearing sunglasses and sarcastic quote, gothic mug gift for her, witchy home decor

First of All I’m a F*ing Delight Funny Coffee Mug | Gothic Skeleton Mug | Gift for Her | Sassy Dark Humor Cup

$21.95 USD

Witchy coffee mug with “Witch’s Brew” design on black gothic mug, witchy home decor and gift for her

Witch’s Brew Witchy Coffee Mug | Witchy Mug with Potion Design | Witchy Home Decor | Cozy Witch Aesthetic Cup

$21.95 USD

Witchy mug with “Patience Brewing” potion design on white coffee mug, witchy home decor and gift for her

Patience Brewing Witchy Coffee Mug | Funny Potion Witchy Mug | Gift for Her | Cozy Witch Aesthetic Mug

$21.95 USD

Enamel pin with witch design on a dark background

Witchy Elixer Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Pin with 'Witch in the Woods' text on a dark background

Witch in the Woods Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Witch-themed keychain with 'Familiar' and 'Witch' text on a dark background.

Pin with 'WITCH' text on a dark fabric background

Witch & Familiar Enamel Pin & Collar Charm Set

$15.00 USD

spellbound & free witchy enamel pin

Spellbound & Free Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Unicorn skull pin with colorful design on a dark surface

Rainbow Skelecorn Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Enamel pin of a house with a purple background

Night Bloom Cottage Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Decorative brooch with celestial design on a dark surface

Midnight Bat Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD