Witchy Gifts $35 or Less | Magical & Affordable Gifts – Pagan Isle Apothecary

Witchy Gifts Under $50

Looking for a magical gift on a budget? You’re in the right place! This collection of witchy gifts $35 or less makes it easy to treat your favorite witch (or yourself!) without breaking the cauldron!

Mystery Coffin Capsules

Mystery Coffin Capsules

$10.00 USD

Cabinet of Curiosities featuring a curated assortment of mystical objects, crystals, and apothecary-inspired items, arranged in a dark, enchanted display for magical decor and discovery.

Cabinet of Curiosities | Witchy Mystery Bags

$22.95 USD

Sold out

Persephone deity crystal candle symbolizing transformation, rebirth, and duality, adorned with crystals and rich tones for seasonal and shadow work rituals.

Persephone crystal candle decorated with symbolic crystals, representing rebirth, balance, and inner transformation.

Persephone Crystal Candle | Rebirth & Shadow Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Lilith deity crystal candle honoring independence and feminine power, designed with bold mystical elements and crystals for empowerment rituals.

Lilith crystal candle infused with powerful crystals, made for autonomy, confidence, and dark feminine energy.

Lilith Crystal Candle | Independence & Power Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Hekate deity crystal candle representing witchcraft, crossroads, and spiritual guidance, crafted with crystals and dark magical symbolism for altar work.

Hekate crystal candle infused with sacred crystals, designed for witchcraft, protection, and liminal rituals

Hekate Crystal Candle | Crossroads & Witchcraft Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Aphrodite deity crystal candle adorned with crystals and romantic tones, inspired by the goddess of love, beauty, and desire for altar rituals and intention work.

Aphrodite crystal candle adorned with ritual crystals, handcrafted for love, beauty, and attraction magic.

Aphrodite Crystal Candle | Beauty & Love Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Nyx deity crystal candle inspired by the primordial goddess of night, featuring deep shadowy tones and crystals for nocturnal rituals and mystical decor.

Nyx crystal candle with deep-toned crystals, crafted for shadow work, dreams, and nocturnal magic.

Nyx Crystal Candle | Night Magic Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Toast At Twilight wax melt blending cozy warmth with a dark twilight aesthetic

Toast at Twilight Wax Melts | Romantic Evening Scent

$6.25 USD

Graveyard Roses wax melt featuring deep rose notes with a dark romantic gothic vibe

Graveyard Roses Wax Melts | Dark Floral Gothic Scent

$6.25 USD

Zombie Zest Fest wax melt with bright citrus tones in a spooky gothic aesthetic

Zombie Zest Fest Wax Melts | Bright & Spooky Citrus

$6.25 USD

Dark apothecary-style Witch’s Brew wax melt with mystical gothic tones

Witch’s Brew Wax Melts | Classic Seasonal Scent

$6.25 USD

Monster Mash wax melt with playful spooky colors and Halloween-inspired styling

Monster Mash Wax Melts | Fun Spooky Scent

$6.25 USD

Dark Unicorn wax melt blending fantasy magic with a dark gothic aesthetic

Dark Unicorn Wax Melts | Sweet Fantasy Scent

$6.25 USD

Freyja deity crystal candle inspired by the Norse goddess of love and magic, adorned with crystals and warm mystical tones for ritual and devotional use.

Freyja crystal candle featuring sacred crystals, created for passion, protection, and Norse-inspired magic.

Freyja Crystal Candle | Love & Strength Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Moonlit Mischief wax melt with magical nighttime vibes and gothic charm

Moonlit Mischief Wax Melts | Cheeky, Spicy Scent

$6.25 USD

Button Eyes wax melt inspired by spooky cute aesthetics and gothic decor

Button Eyes Wax Melts | Sweet & Spooky Scent

$6.25 USD

Funny coffee mug with skeleton wearing sunglasses and sarcastic quote, gothic mug gift for her, witchy home decor

First of All I’m a F*ing Delight Funny Coffee Mug | Gothic Skeleton Mug | Gift for Her | Sassy Dark Humor Cup

$21.95 USD

Witchy coffee mug with “Witch’s Brew” design on black gothic mug, witchy home decor and gift for her

Witch’s Brew Witchy Coffee Mug | Witchy Mug with Potion Design | Witchy Home Decor | Cozy Witch Aesthetic Cup

$21.95 USD

Witchy mug with “Patience Brewing” potion design on white coffee mug, witchy home decor and gift for her

Patience Brewing Witchy Coffee Mug | Funny Potion Witchy Mug | Gift for Her | Cozy Witch Aesthetic Mug

$21.95 USD

Medusa deity crystal candle symbolizing protection, rage, and reclaimed power, crafted with dark tones and crystals for shadow work and altar decor.

Medusa crystal candle adorned with protective crystals, crafted for warding, strength, and empowerment magic.

Medusa Crystal Candle | Protection & Power Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Loki deity crystal candle inspired by the Norse trickster god, featuring dynamic magical energy and crystal accents for chaos magic and transformation work.

Loki crystal candle with dynamic ritual crystals, designed for transformation, mischief, and personal evolution.

Loki Crystal Candle | Chaos & Transformation Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Dionysus deity crystal candle celebrating pleasure, chaos, and liberation, featuring rich colors and crystals for ecstatic rituals and bold altar decor.

Dionysus crystal candle with vibrant crystals, designed for celebration, pleasure, and uninhibited magic.

Dionysus Crystal Candle | Joy & Release Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Anubis deity crystal candle inspired by the Egyptian god of protection and the afterlife, featuring dark mystical tones and crystal adornments for ritual use.

Anubis crystal candle featuring dark ritual crystals, created for protection, transition, and ancestral magic

Anubis Crystal Candle | Protection & Guidance Spell Candle

$37.95 USD

Sold out

Enamel pin with witch design on a dark background

Witchy Elixer Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Pin with 'Witch in the Woods' text on a dark background

Witch in the Woods Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Witch-themed keychain with 'Familiar' and 'Witch' text on a dark background.

Pin with 'WITCH' text on a dark fabric background

Witch & Familiar Enamel Pin & Collar Charm Set

$15.00 USD

spellbound & free witchy enamel pin

Spellbound & Free Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Unicorn skull pin with colorful design on a dark surface

Rainbow Skelecorn Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Enamel pin of a house with a purple background

Night Bloom Cottage Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD

Decorative brooch with celestial design on a dark surface

Midnight Bat Enamel Pin

$8.00 USD