Step into the unknown with Pagan Isle’s Mystery Boxes, where every box is a spellbinding surprise. Our 3 tiers all have a touch of magic, each mystery box may contain witchy trinkets, exclusive handmade items, crystals, enchanted accessories, and more. Perfect for witches, collectors, and lovers of the mystical—these boxes sell fast, so claim yours before they vanish into the mist!

Starter Pre-Made Mystery Box
This box is NOT curated, it is pre-made! Whispers of the woods await in this starter mystery box. Moss & Moonlight is perfect for the everyday forest witch, filled with essential tools, crystals, and mystical trinkets inspired by moonlit groves and ancient magic. Expect 5–7 witchy treasures that feel like they were gathered on a twilight stroll through enchanted woods.

Starter Curated Mystery Box
This box is curated just for you, make sure to leave us a note with things you love so we can make you your own special box! It’s the easiest (and most enchanting) way to discover new treasures you didn’t even know you needed!

Premium Pre-Made Mystery Box
This box is NOT curated, it is pre-made! This our most exclusive mystery experience. Each box is a decadent trove of rare, high-vibrational offerings: artisan-made altar pieces, enchanted wearables, and powerful relics rooted in old-world forest magic. With 8+ deluxe items, this box is fit for a witch of ancient bloodlines and boundless power!

Premium Curated Mystery Box
This box is curated just for you, make sure to leave us a note with things you love so we can make you your own special box! This is the ultimate VIP mystery experience for the most powerful witches!